While We Watched: Assessing the Impact of the Satellite Sentinel Project by Nathaniel A. Raymond et al.

facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmail

Click here to view as PDF || Shop the Entire Current Issue- The Integration of Regions ||  Return to The Integration of Regions index


Nathaniel A. Raymond, Benjamin I. Davies, Brittany L. Card, Ziad Al Achkar, and Isaac L. Baker

The authors are currently the staff of the Harvard Humanitarian Initiative’s (HHI) Signal Program on Human Security and Technology. Between December 2010 and June 2012, the authors were the operations staff and analysts of the Satellite Sentinel Project and were based at HHI.


Ad Damazin Convoy. Image c/o HHI and DigitalGlobe.

Ad Damazin Convoy. Image c/o HHI and DigitalGlobe.

When mass atrocities occur in conflict zones, corroborated, publicly available information about events happening in near-real time is often in short supply, if available at all. The difficulty of obtaining credible information during mass atrocities may impede international response to these complex events and, as a result, can increase the vulnerability of at risk populations. The recent, public deployment of remote sensing and data collection technologies during the alleged mass atrocities in Sudan provides insight into what potential impact and challenges these platforms may have in these scenarios.

The experience of the Satellite Sentinel Project (SSP) suggests that attempting to enhance the situational awareness of policymakers and the public does not appear by itself, at least in the case of Sudan, to directly affect whether, and to what degree, governments respond to mass atrocities as they occur. This article offers an overview of the relationship between the SSP reports published by the Harvard Humanitarian Initiative (HHI)1 and international policy makers. It also explores SSP’s use of technology and the development of its methodology, identifying possible lessons to guide future mass atrocity response operations.

A Radical Proposition

When SSP publicly launched in December 2010,2 the ensuing headlines ostensibly focused on two things: the application of technology (satellites), and its co-founder and patron, actor George Clooney. SSP’s stated mission was to help prevent a return to full-scale war between Sudan and then-southern Sudan through satellite monitoring of threats to civilians along the contested border.3 Implicit in the ambitious objective of preventing the civil war was the aspiration that the surveillance would affect the policies of the international community in ways that benefited vulnerable populations.

For SSP to become operational, two obstacles had to first be overcome: Regular access to the necessary volume of satellite imagery over the right locations and the means to immediately analyze relevant imagery and non-imagery data. The necessary imagery access and analysis support was provided by DigitalGlobe, a high-resolution satellite imagery provider. However, HHI, initially with the support of UN satellite imagery analysts, was responsible for solving the second challenge: collecting and interpreting high volumes of satellite and non-satellite data in twenty-four hour cycles.

SSP’s radical proposition was that persistent near-real time remote surveillance could prevent or curtail the risks to vulnerable populations in Sudan and southern Sudan from gross human rights abuses.4 SSP thought that achieving this effect could provide a blueprint for scaling this approach to other, future mass atrocity scenarios. If SSP did not have that effect, at the very least, evidence of alleged atrocities would be captured and documented to a degree previously impossible. No civilian platform similar to SSP had been built before due to high costs of satellite imagery and the absence of the methodology required for managing vast streams of relevant data.

Satellites, traditionally used by governments, provide otherwise unattainable, contemporaneous information about events occurring in non-permissive environments. Orbiting hundreds of miles above the Earth, their sensors collect unique data about certain observable objects (i.e. tanks, planes, burned buildings, etc.) from places not easily accessible from the ground.

At the time SSP was launched, approximately two weeks before the January 2011 referendum deciding southern Sudan’s secession from Sudan, credible data about events on-the-ground were scant. Violence was escalating. Specific ethnic groups in Abyei, Blue Nile, and South Kordofan were seen by analysts as potential targets for atrocities by the government of Sudan. The information available about the events in these areas was often second-hand and largely impossible to confirm. The international community had minimal capacities for collecting impartial information and freely assisting civilians inside critical areas of Sudan due to restrictions on their freedom of movement.

United Nations Mission in Sudan (UNMIS) peacekeepers operated in Abyei and South Kordofan only until their mandate expired on 9 July 2011. Some international humanitarian groups were allowed by the Government of Sudan to stay in parts of the region until August that year, though heavy restrictions were placed on their activities. Because of these limitations, satellite monitoring was, at the time, SSP’s most optimal option for collecting better corroborated information.

A New Methodology for a Costly Technology

SSP represents a substantial paradigm shift from traditional, often retrospective, collection of evidence corroborating alleged human rights violations. Instead, unprecedented access to recently captured imagery allowed SSP analysts to proactively anticipate some of these events. Evidence of enhanced fortifications or the presence of heavy equipment necessary to transport armored vehicles, for example, became harbingers of potential threats to specific civilian populations.

Unlike government geospatial analysts, HHI researchers began their work with limited precedents and pedagogy for guiding this tempo and volume of analysis in a humanitarian setting. A new methodology was needed for SSP’s operations. The resulting approach is a hybrid of tactics for assessing military movements, humanitarian indicators, and melding together different streams of data into a more fused view of crisis events.

DigitalGlobe’s constellation of satellites travels each day around the Earth in a geosynchronous trajectory, passing over the north and south poles as they orbit. The amount of images collected by SSP in such short periods of time allowed for a level and tempo of “refresh” (i.e. collection of new imagery) over key locations that made the observation of micro-changes in a village or a military base possible. HHI also had to collect, geo-code and sometimes translate non-imagery data. This data is essential for making sense of imagery. To address this issue, HHI staff geo-coded all relevant data in English, Arabic, and other languages by time stamps and geographic coordinates.

HHI researchers then fused together these two independent streams of data. The result is a previously unavailable, non-classified tool for situational awareness during alleged atrocity events. However, HHI analysts faced numerous challenges employing this new capacity.

The most important issue was the inherent limitations on analyzing remote sensing data without reliable ground confirmation. Satellites could offer a rare glimpse into the highly non-permissive Sudan-South Sudan border areas. However, imagery still represents only a single source of data about alleged events within a dynamic conflict zone. Though the HHI team strove to draw definitive conclusions about the conflict, remote sensing analysis alone could not result in conclusive knowledge of a situation, only interpretations.

HHI researchers recognized that remotely monitoring the conflict meant that reaching a consistent threshold of certainty about events on the ground was impossible. Reflecting this reality, HHI wrote all SSP reports in caveated language. For example, an image of a main battle tank was never simply reported as “a tank.” That “tank” was always reported as an object “consistent” with a specific type of tank. Each specific type of tank had to be identified by measuring the object and comparing it to public databases about what vehicles or weapons are reportedly in the armed actors’ arsenal.

As a result, HHI developed its own standards for what constituted appropriate levels of certainty to first reach and then release analytic conclusions. These standards enabled the HHI team to produce an experimental body of work that was both rich with retrospective data and of potential value to policymakers and the public. As the scope of reports collected and the archive of relevant imagery grew, HHI improved these systems for identifying and assessing intersections between imagery and geo-coded data.

Soon, HHI analysts were able to detect and corroborate evidence of abuses in a highly non-permissive environment. This approach allowed HHI to identify repeating patterns of behavior derived from public reports. Overlaid on recent imagery, these intersecting clusters of interrelated, digital information were critical in deciding where satellites should collect imagery.

This approach enabled SSP to become increasingly predictive. SSP moved from a traditional “documentation posture” into a more predictive “detection posture.” Analysts were thus able to better target their collection of imagery to be more relevant to the real time security of vulnerable populations. This move towards prediction forced HHI researchers to weigh the unintended consequences of publicizing information and images about vulnerable populations when the audience included the parties to the conflict themselves. This task was especially difficult given SSP’s access to near-real time satellite imagery and the ability to rapidly share those images globally through the international and Sudanese domestic media.

As SSP worked to minimize the risk associated with these near-real time products, the challenge for the project was neither an absence of reports presenting compelling evidence of apparent mass atrocities, nor media exposure for its findings. Instead, the primary challenge was leveraging SSP’s unique information to motivate international response to the alleged abuses in Sudan.

Barriers to Impact

Analysis of SSP’s eighteen month pilot phase identifies multiple factors that may have limited the impact of SSP’s reports in affecting the policy response of the U.S. government and others towards the crisis. One key factor that may have significantly limited SSP’s ability to bring about policy changes was the perception of the project as being biased against the Government of Sudan and sympathetic towards South Sudan. Arguments concerning bias or the equal coverage of armed actors in SSP’s reports are not without merit. They are actually critical to take into account when assessing the SSP model.

The SSP partner responsible for the project’s communications and advocacy strategy, the Enough Project, and its funding source, Not On Our Watch, both had clearly stated positions against the Bashir regime. While HHI produced SSP’s reports, SSP’s founders, George Clooney and John Prendergast, a co-founder of the Enough Project, engaged in a high-profile advocacy campaign against the policies and leadership of the Government of Sudan. This included a March 2012 trip to Sudan’s Nuba Mountains region, as well as the subsequent arrest of George Clooney and other public figures, including Members of Congress, at the Sudanese Embassy in Washington, DC. Looking back on the first eighteen months of SSP, the public attention primarily centered either on the SSP’s technological uniqueness or the involvement of its famous founder, George Clooney. SSP’s novelty and its association with a celebrity often received more focus than the ramifications of its analysis for foreign policy.

Although all SSP reports during the pilot phase were independently produced by HHI, they were published under the SSP brand. The Enough Project acted as the delivery mechanism for SSP research products while simultaneously advocating its own policy recommendations on Sudan. Despite efforts to differentiate roles within the consortium, this structural reality reinforced the perception that SSP was an advocacy non-governmental organization (NGO) targeting President Bashir and the Sudanese leadership. For the high profile nature of the project, public questions or criticism concerning these core operational dynamics were rare.

Another factor that may have hindered the ability of SSP products to influence policy decisions was that policymakers possessed independent sources of information about events in Sudan. This information includes intelligence analysis and more advanced, routine satellite access to the region. If this information provided more comprehensive conclusions different to those reached by SSP, it could cast doubt on the SSP’s findings.

Due to the classified nature of government intelligence, SSP analysts were not able to compare the outcomes of their analysis with the totality of information available to policymakers. Compounding this issue, even if SSP’s reporting was timely and accurate, the true calculus of what was necessary at the policy level for any type of intervention in Sudan was and remains unknown. These extremely significant blind spots made it impossible for SSP to know what credibility or relevance their reports would have when they reached those in a decisive position to act.

A three shot progression of buildup of technicals at the state police barracks before they can be seen distributed throughout Kadguli engaging in what all evidence points to as house to house killing that later resulted in the mass graves. Image c/o HHI and DigitalGlobe.

A three shot progression of buildup of technicals at the state police barracks before they can be seen distributed throughout Kadguli engaging in what all evidence points to as house to house killing.  Image c/o HHI and DigitalGlobe.

SSP’s Contribution

SSP confronted the reality that regardless of the publicity resulting from its reports, it was unable to catalyze timely or robust action within policy communities. As a consequence, the impact of SSP was an indirect but critical one: it generated public attention and made it necessary for policymakers to pay attention.

The project’s published reports became recognized as an otherwise unavailable, contemporaneous source of information about the conflict in Sudan. SSP’s ability to collect, analyze and release information in near-real time about potential threats to civilians, as much as the findings themselves, made its reporting more relevant and timely than other available information. To enhance this effect, SSP initially publicized each report through international news bureaus in East Africa, releasing them around 7am East Africa Time, in an attempt to better inform populations in danger. SSP’s reports became a widely cited resource on the evolving situation in Sudan by a range of policy actors, including the International Criminal Court,7 the U.S. Congress, UN agencies, and others.

The project represents a critical step towards ascertaining what is required to transform the remote surveillance act into a means of better protecting civilians inside atrocity producing settings. For example, in the case of Kadugli, South Kordofan, during the summer of 2011, SSP conducted the first ever non-governmental, remote collection of alleged evidence of mass grave sites in a non-permissive environment. This occurred while reported systematic killings were ongoing.8 SSP also visually confirmed the looting of the World Food Program facility in Abyei9 and detected SAF forces moving to attack civilian areas in Blue Nile.10 These successes resulted from unique insights that only remote-sensing technologies could deliver; improving the speed, agility and tempo with which evidence could be collected and presented for the benefit of vulnerable populations.

Through the use of a robust methodology and advanced technology, SSP hoped to change the balance of consequences for both armed actors in Sudan and policymakers around the world. So far, the evidence does not show that SSP met that objective. However, by advancing the practice of near-real time monitoring and documentation of alleged mass atrocities, SSP did help ensure that when policymakers and the public will not serve as rescuers, they will at least become witnesses.


1 HHI led SSP’s data collection, analysis, and report production during SSP’s eighteen months pilot phase from December 2010 until June 2012. HHI withdrew from SSP to found the Signal Program on Human Security and Technology to conduct research on the emerging operational and ethical issues related to the use of information communication technologies during complex humanitarian disasters.

2 Mark Benjamin, “Clooney’s ‘Antigenocide Paparazzi’: Watching Sudan,” Time Magazine, December 28, 2010, Internet, http://www.time.com/time/ magazine/article/0%2C9171%2C2040211%2C00. html

3 Satellite Sentinel Project, “Our Story”, n.d., http://satsentinel.org/our-story.

4 Patrick Meier, “Will Using ‘Live’ Satellite Imagery to Prevent War in the Sudan Actually Work?” iRevolution, 20 December 2010, Internet, http:// irevolution.net/2010/12/30/sat-sentinel-project/.

5 Larisa Epatko, “George Clooney on Sudan: ‘It Gets in Your Bloodstream’.” PBS Newshour, 14 March 2012, Internet, http://www.pbs.org/newshour/rundown/2012/03/george-clooney-on-sudan.html.

6 Dana Hughes, “George Clooney Arrested at Sudanese Embassy,” ABC News, 16 March 2012, Internet, http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/OTUS/ george-clooney-arrested-sudan-embassy-washing- ton-dc/story?id=15936415#.UW2YYyuG0bo.

7 Mark Benjamin, “George Clooney’s Satellites Build a War Crimes Case Against an Alleged War Criminal,” Time Magazine, 3 December 2011, Internet, http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,2101425,00.html.

8 Satellite Sentinel Project, Crime Scene: Evidence of Mass Graves in Kadugli, July 14, 2011, Internet, http://satsentinel.org/sites/default/files/SSP%20 16%20Final%20Smaller.pdf.

9 Satellite Sentinel Project, Burned to the Ground, May 28, 2011, Internet, http://hhi.harvard.edu/sites/ default/files/publications/burned-to-the-ground.pdf.

10 Satellite Sentinel Project, State of Emergency: Threat of Imminent SAF Attack on Kurmuk, Blue Nile, September 23, 2011, Internet, http://www. satsentinel.org/sites/default/files/Satellite Sentinel Project report 092311.pdf.


 

facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmail

51 Comments

  • February 24, 2017

    ig

    I every time used to read post in news papers but now as I am a
    user of net so from now I am using net for articles, thanks to
    web.

  • February 25, 2017

    ig

    It’s perfect time to make a few plans for the long run and
    it is time to be happy. I have learn this post and if I may I
    want to counsel you some attention-grabbing issues or suggestions.

    Maybe you could write next articles regarding this article.
    I desire to learn more issues about it!

  • March 4, 2017

    augustaairconditioning

    Yes! Finally something about ig.

  • Its like you read my mind! You appear to know a lot about this, like
    you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you
    can do with some pics to drive the message home a little bit, but other than that, this
    is excellent blog. An excellent read. I will definitely be back.

  • […] television are a better option than expanding the information technologies. Or could it be better not to use technology at all? asks Dette. Even if Pieterse says that the digital divide is not a technical issue, but rather a […]

  • March 11, 2017

    Augusto de Arruda Botelho

    Hi, always i used to check webpage posts here in the early hours in the daylight, since
    i enjoy to find out more and more.

  • March 18, 2017

    Danial

    I all the time used to study article in news
    papers but now as I am a user of net thus from now I am using net for articles, thanks to web.

  • March 20, 2017

    Magwood1851@gmail.com

    Great post. Thank you for your time in helping me learn on the matter.

  • March 20, 2017

    loss of hair

    Hi there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it’s truly informative.
    I’m going to watch out for brussels. I will be grateful if you continue this in future.
    Lots of people will be benefited from your writing.
    Cheers!

  • March 20, 2017

    mini site templates

    You actually make it appear so easy with your presentation but I find this matter to be really one
    thing that I believe I’d by no means understand. It kind of feels too complicated and
    very large for me. I’m looking ahead on your subsequent publish, I’ll attempt to get the grasp of it!

  • March 20, 2017

    Deck builder

    Great site. Thank you for your time in helping me learn about this.

  • March 20, 2017

    travel item

    Hi! I’ve been reading your web site for a while
    now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Lubbock Texas!
    Just wanted to tell you keep up the fantastic job!

  • March 20, 2017

    Concetta

    Greetings from Florida! I’m bored at work so I decided to browse your website
    on my iphone during lunch break. I enjoy the knowledge you provide here and can’t wait
    to take a look when I get home. I’m shocked at how fast your blog loaded on my mobile ..
    I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, awesome site!

  • March 20, 2017

    Chassidy

    Hi all, here every one is sharing these kinds of know-how, thus it’s pleasant to read
    this website, and I used to pay a visit this webpage everyday.

  • March 20, 2017

    Celesta

    I am now not certain where you are getting your info, however good topic.
    I needs to spend some time finding out much
    more or working out more. Thanks for excellent info I used to be looking
    for this info for my mission.

  • March 20, 2017

    Chloe

    Good post. I learn something new and challenging on sites I
    stumbleupon on a daily basis. It will always be exciting to read through content from other writers
    and practice something from their websites.

  • March 21, 2017

    Elma

    whoah this weblog is great i love studying your posts.

    Keep up the great work! You realize, a lot of individuals are
    looking round for this info, you could aid them
    greatly.

  • March 21, 2017

    PhilZendia

    I must say you have high quality posts here.

    But your website is not even in TOP 20 google’s search results.
    I can help you to rank your site, send me email if you are interested – philzendia@o2.pl

  • March 21, 2017

    Veronique

    I’m extremely impressed with your writing skills as well as
    with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you modify
    it yourself? Anyway keep up the excellent quality writing, it is
    rare to see a great blog like this one these days.

  • March 21, 2017

    Angelica

    It’s awesome for me to have a website, which is good designed for my experience.
    thanks admin

  • March 21, 2017

    Ivy

    Hello to all, how is everything, I think every one is getting
    more from this web site, and your views are fastidious for new people.

  • If some one wants to be updated with most recent
    technologies therefore he must be pay a quick visit this site and be up to date all the time.

  • March 21, 2017

    Lenora

    After looking at a handful of the blog posts on your website, I really
    like your technique of blogging. I saved it to my bookmark webpage list and will be checking back in the near future.
    Please visit my web site as well and let me know how you
    feel.

  • March 21, 2017

    Silvia

    I was curious if you ever thought of changing the layout of your site?

    Its very well written; I love what youve got to say. But maybe you could a
    little more in the way of content so people could connect with it better.
    Youve got an awful lot of text for only having 1 or two images.
    Maybe you could space it out better?

  • March 21, 2017

    Betsey

    Link exchange is nothing else however it is just placing the
    other person’s blog link on your page at proper place and other person will also
    do same for you.

  • March 23, 2017

    Kira

    Great post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed!
    Very helpful info particularly the ultimate section 🙂 I deal with such information a
    lot. I used to be seeking this particular information for a very lengthy time.

    Thank you and best of luck.

  • March 23, 2017

    Georges Sadala

    Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely well written article.
    I will be sure to bookmark it and come back to read more
    of your useful information. Thanks for the post.
    I’ll certainly return.

  • March 23, 2017

    Egli Diana Pinto

    Very great post. I simply stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I’ve
    really enjoyed surfing around your weblog posts. In any case I’ll be
    subscribing for your rss feed and I hope you write once more
    soon!

  • March 23, 2017

    Georges Sadala

    Hello to every body, it’s my first go to see
    of this webpage; this webpage includes awesome and really
    fine data designed for visitors.

  • Yes! Finally someone writes about financial advisors.

  • March 24, 2017

    car computer exchange

    Undeniably consider that which you stated.
    Your favorite reason appeared to be at the net the easiest thing to take note of.
    I say to you, I definitely get annoyed at the same time
    as folks think about concerns that they just do not recognise about.
    You controlled to hit the nail upon the top as neatly as defined out the whole thing without having side-effects ,
    other people could take a signal. Will probably be back to get more.
    Thank you

  • March 24, 2017

    Itamar Serpa Fernandes

    Wonderful blog! I found it while surfing around on Yahoo News.
    Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
    I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there!
    Thanks

  • March 24, 2017

    banks exist everywhere

    Excellent web site you’ve got here.. It’s hard to find quality writing like yours nowadays.

    I honestly appreciate people like you! Take care!!

  • March 24, 2017

    Augustus

    This site was… how do you say it? Relevant!! Finally I’ve found something that helped me.
    Thank you!

  • March 25, 2017

    Jerold

    This info is invaluable. Where can I find
    out more?

  • March 26, 2017

    Beverly

    Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I
    have truly enjoyed browsing your blog posts.
    After all I will be subscribing to your feed and I
    hope you write again soon!

  • March 26, 2017

    Itamar Serpa Fernandes

    Your mode of describing everything in this article is genuinely good, all can without difficulty
    understand it, Thanks a lot.

  • March 26, 2017

    Egli Diana Pinto

    I am genuinely thankful to the owner of this website who has shared this impressive piece of
    writing at here.

  • March 26, 2017

    Egli Diana Pinto

    I just like the valuable info you supply to your articles.

    I will bookmark your blog and test again right here frequently.

    I am somewhat sure I will learn many new stuff right here!
    Good luck for the next!

  • March 27, 2017

    windows car pc

    You actually make it seem so easy along with your presentation however I find this matter to be actually something that I believe I’d by no means understand.

    It seems too complex and very vast for me. I’m looking ahead for your subsequent put up, I will try to get the dangle of
    it!

  • March 27, 2017

    Garrett

    Hi! Someone in my Myspace group shared this website with us so I
    came to take a look. I’m definitely loving the information. I’m book-marking and will be tweeting this to my followers!
    Exceptional blog and great design and style.

  • March 27, 2017

    hydrogen car

    This is my first time visit at here and i am in fact happy to read everthing at one place.

  • March 27, 2017

    Jamie

    This website definitely has all of the info I wanted about this subject and didn’t know who to ask.

  • March 28, 2017

    winter workouts

    Your style is really unique in comparison to other folks I have read stuff from.
    I appreciate you for posting when you have the opportunity, Guess I
    will just bookmark this page.

  • March 28, 2017

    sales life

    Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account
    it. Look advanced to more added agreeable from you!
    However, how can we communicate?

  • March 29, 2017

    Sophie

    What i do not realize is in fact how you are
    not actually a lot more smartly-favored than you may be now.
    You are so intelligent. You understand therefore considerably with regards to this subject, produced me
    individually imagine it from numerous varied angles. Its like men and
    women are not interested until it is something to accomplish with Girl gaga!
    Your own stuffs great. Always maintain it up!

  • March 29, 2017

    Egli Diana Pinto

    Hello, I read your blog regularly. Your humoristic style
    is awesome, keep up the good work!

  • March 30, 2017

    spinning teacher tells

    Magnificent web site. Plenty of useful information here.
    I am sending it to a few buddies ans additionally sharing in delicious.
    And of course, thanks for your sweat!

  • March 30, 2017

    bike ride

    This article will assist the internet people for setting up new blog or
    even a weblog from start to end.

Leave a Reply